The Pope Is Not Excommunicating JD Vance. Bet Accordingly.
PredictIt is offering 50¢ on a coin flip that isn't a coin flip. We're backing up the truck on NO.
Rough week to be a Catholic political junkie. Between the latest Vatican leaks, the Vance confirmation hearings for Supreme Court nominees getting ugly, and whatever satire site started the excommunication rumor last Thursday — half of political Twitter has lost the plot. PredictIt traders included.
We've only got one pick today. But it's the kind of line that makes you wonder if anyone at PredictIt is actually awake.
Will the Pope Excommunicate JD Vance Before 2028?
The market has this at 50¢ YES. A coin flip. On the Pope formally excommunicating a sitting US Vice President.
Our model has it at 2%. And honestly, 2% feels generous.
Here's what's happening: a satire piece went semi-viral, Snopes already stamped it fake, and now the YES side is sitting at 50¢ because degens see a binary and assume it must be close to even. It's not. Formal papal excommunication of a sitting US VP has never happened in American history. Not Kennedy. Not Biden. Not anyone.
The process itself takes months to years of canonical review. Pope Leo XIV has shown zero appetite for picking that fight. And Vance, whatever you think of him politically, hasn't done anything that comes within a mile of the canonical triggers (heresy, schism, apostasy — not tariff policy).
So you're getting 50¢ on NO for something our model prices at 98¢. The AI gave this an S grade and an edge score of -48, which is basically it screaming at us through the terminal.
What kills the bet: PredictIt resolution risk is real. These weird political novelty markets can sit forever, your capital gets tied up, and PredictIt's 5% withdrawal fee + 10% on profits eats into the edge. You're also locked in until 2028 or until the market resolves early. If you need liquid capital for Election Night, this isn't the play.
But if you've got sideline money and you're comfortable letting it cook for 15 months, this is as close to free as prediction markets get. The only way you lose is if Pope Leo XIV wakes up tomorrow and decides to rewrite 2,000 years of canon law specifically to spite the VP. Possible! Just not 50% possible.
The TL;DR
One pick. One screamer. NO on Pope-Vance excommunication at 50¢. The market is pricing noise. We're pricing history.
Yes we wrote 400 words about papal canon law to justify a prediction market bet. We know.
GL out there. Don't excommunicate anyone we wouldn't.
Our Calls From This Date
These are the exact picks our AI flagged on October 7.