PredictIt Thinks Meloni Is a Coinflip to Bounce. PredictIt Is on Drugs.
One market has Meloni at 48¢ to leave next. Another has her at 4¢ to leave all year. Pick a lane.
Meloni just wrapped another weekend of looking annoyingly stable while the rest of Europe sets itself on fire. Macron's government is held together with scotch tape, Scholz got replaced months ago, and Zelenskyy is, you know, at war. And somehow PredictIt thinks the Italian PM is the one most likely to pack her bags next. Make it make sense.
Which European leader leaves office next? — Meloni NO at 48¢
The market has Meloni at 48¢ to be the next one out. That's basically a coinflip. Against a field that includes Macron at ~50%, who is one bad croissant away from a no-confidence vote.
Here's the kicker: Kalshi has Meloni at 4¢ to leave office at any point in 2026. Four cents. Over the entire year. And PredictIt is pricing her at 48¢ to leave *next*, which by definition has to be a smaller number than 'leaves at all.'
Two markets, same person, same question, and the prices aren't even in the same zip code. One of them is wrong and we're pretty sure it's not the one with real money and real volume.
For reference, the Meloni-adjacent names on the board — Sánchez, Merz, Zelenskyy — are all sitting around 5%. Meloni's political situation looks a lot more like theirs than it does Macron's. She's got a working coalition, decent approval numbers, and no immediate scandal cooking. The 48¢ is a PredictIt liquidity artifact, not a real read on reality.
The AI tagged this S-grade with a true probability closer to 10%. Which means you're getting paid 52¢ on something that should pay you maybe 90¢. That's the kind of gap you don't see on efficient markets. You see it on PredictIt because PredictIt is held together by seven guys and a Google Sheet.
What kills it: Italian politics are Italian politics. Coalitions have collapsed over less than a bad lunch. If Salvini wakes up tomorrow and decides he wants the big chair, this whole thesis gets a lot more interesting for the YES side. The edge is real but the floor isn't zero.
Still — you have a market telling you 48%, another market telling you 4%, and a fundamentals case that lines up with the 4%. We'll take that trade every day of the week.
The bigger lesson
Cross-market arbitrage on political props is one of the last soft spots in this whole ecosystem. Kalshi has real volume and real traders. PredictIt has caps, fees, and a user base that treats it like fantasy football. When the two disagree by 40+ points on the same event, you don't need to overthink which one is wrong.
You just need to click NO before someone else notices.
GL out there. If Meloni resigns tomorrow we never wrote this.
Our Calls From This Date
These are the exact picks our AI flagged on October 5.
Which of these 10 European leaders will leave office next? → Giorgia Meloni